By Dustin Hanke, Founder, EpicShifts · Updated June 2026
We compared each scheduler on the factors that change the monthly bill and the day-to-day use for shift-based teams: pricing model (flat-rate vs per-user vs per-location), employee limits and free-plan caps, payroll and POS integrations, mobile experience for hourly staff, and scheduling-specific features like shift swaps and open-shift coverage. Pricing reflects each vendor’s own public pricing as of June 2026; quote-only products are labeled as such and we never estimate a hidden price. Pros and cons summarize each vendor’s public pricing pages and recurring themes in G2 and Capterra reviews. EpicShifts is our own product — we mark it clearly, and every competitor claim is verifiable on the vendor’s site.
| Tool | Best for | Starting price | Free plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| EpicShifts | Flat-rate pricing with unlimited employees | Free, then $39/mo flat | Yes — 10 employees |
| When I Work | Small, stable teams that want a polished per-user app | ~$2.50/user/mo | No (14-day trial) |
| Deputy | Operations that need demand forecasting | ~$5/user/mo (+$30/mo min) | No (30-day trial) |
| Homebase | Small businesses that also want hiring and payroll | $30/location/mo | Yes — 1 location |
| Connecteam | Deskless teams that want one app for everything | ~$29/mo (first 30 users) | Yes — up to 10 users |
| Sling (by Toast) | Teams that want the most generous free plan | ~$2/user/mo | Yes — up to 30 users |
Flat-rate pricing with unlimited employees on every paid plan, the Open Shifts Marketplace (post, claim, swap, and cover across locations), and schedule-tied messaging. A free plan runs a single location for up to 10 employees so you can try it. The pitch is predictability: your bill doesn’t climb as you hire, which is where per-user tools like When I Work and Deputy get expensive past 15–20 people. It’s newer than the incumbents and leads with scheduling rather than bundled payroll, so you connect your existing payroll provider.
Flat $39/mo with unlimited employees — predictable as you grow
Open Shifts Marketplace for fast, cross-location coverage
Free plan (single location, up to 10 employees); every paid plan is flat-price with unlimited staff
Newer than established players like When I Work and Deputy
Fewer third-party integrations today (more rolling out)
No built-in payroll — connect your existing provider
A long-established scheduler with a top-rated mobile app and polished drag-and-drop scheduling, shift swaps, and availability. Clock-in verification is strong — geofencing, photo verification, early-clock-in limits. Pricing is per user, starting at $2.50/user/month (Essentials), and there’s no free plan, just a 14-day trial. Two things surprise buyers: time tracking is a paid add-on rather than bundled, and per-user pricing effectively jumps when you add a second location. Reviewers also report occasional bugs and inconsistent support.
Top-rated mobile app and polished scheduling UX
Strong clock-in verification (geofence, photo)
Mature, with broad payroll and POS integrations
No free plan — 14-day trial only
Time tracking is a paid add-on; per-user cost climbs
Adding a second location effectively raises the per-user rate
Powerful drag-and-drop auto-scheduling with demand forecasting, wage budgeting, and labor-law compliance baked into schedules — its forecasting and automation are among the best-regarded in the category. It suits mid-size and multi-location operations with enterprise controls like SSO and custom roles. Pricing is per user from $5/month (Lite) with a $30/month minimum spend, and there’s no free plan (30-day trial). The catch is real cost: HR, advanced analytics, and payroll are paid add-ons, support is limited (no phone; live chat on Pro only), and some reviewers find it complex to set up.
Best-in-class auto-scheduling and demand forecasting
Labor-law compliance built into schedules
Enterprise controls (SSO, custom roles)
Per-user pricing plus a $30/mo minimum; key features are paid add-ons
Limited support — no phone, live chat on Pro only
Setup can be complex for smaller teams
An all-in-one that bundles scheduling with time tracking, hiring, and optional payroll, and it’s genuinely easy for non-technical owners. The free Basic plan covers a single location. Paid plans price per location — Essentials starts around $30/month ($24 billed annually) — and include unlimited employees per site. Watch the add-ons: payroll runs about $39/month plus $6 per active employee, and multi-location operators pay full price per site, so costs climb as you grow.
Genuinely usable free tier for one location
All-in-one: scheduling, time tracking, hiring, optional payroll
Easy for non-technical owners — minimal setup
Per-location pricing adds up fast for multi-site operators
Add-ons (payroll, tips, tasks) stack on top of the base price
Customer support is a common complaint in reviews
A broad, mobile-first all-in-one for deskless teams — scheduling, time clock, tasks, chat, and HR/training in one app — with a best-in-class free tier covering all features for up to 10 users. Paid pricing is per “hub” (Operations, Communications, HR), flat for the first 30 users at about $29/month (billed annually) per hub. The trade-offs: needing all three hubs means three subscriptions, so cost climbs for larger orgs, and scheduling is broad rather than deep (no dedicated call-off/last-minute-absence tracking). Reviewers note admin setup can be click-heavy.
True all-in-one for deskless teams (scheduling, chat, tasks, HR)
Excellent free tier — all features up to 10 users
Mobile-first and easy for employees
Per-hub pricing — needing all three hubs means three subscriptions
Scheduling is broad but not as deep as specialists
Admin setup can be click-heavy
One of the most generous free tiers available — full scheduling, shift swaps, and team messaging for up to 30 users at no cost — and low per-user paid plans at roughly $2/user/month (Premium) to $4/user (Business). It’s a strong value pick for smaller teams, with built-in messaging and a newsfeed beyond bare scheduling. Reviewers note the mobile app can lag or fall out of sync with desktop, and auto-scheduling, deeper reporting, and POS integration are gated behind the Business tier.
One of the most generous free plans (up to 30 users)
Low per-user paid pricing; built-in team messaging
Tight Toast POS integration on paid tiers
Mobile app can lag or sync poorly with desktop
Auto-scheduling and reporting gated behind the Business tier
Free plan caps at 30 users
For flat-rate pricing with unlimited employees and a built-in shift marketplace, EpicShifts is a top pick. When I Work and Deputy are strong polished per-user options, Homebase and Connecteam are broad all-in-ones, and Sling leads on free plans.
Sling is free for up to 30 users and EpicShifts is free for up to 10 employees — both let you run real schedules at no cost, and EpicShifts’ paid plans are flat-price with unlimited employees once you outgrow free. Homebase Basic is free for a single location. When I Work and Deputy offer only trials.
For very small teams, per-user pricing (e.g., $2.50–$5/user) can be cheaper. Past roughly 15–20 employees, flat-rate pricing like EpicShifts’ $39/month usually wins because the bill stops climbing as you hire.
Flat-rate, unlimited employees, and the Open Shifts Marketplace. Start free — no credit card.
Dustin Hanke, Founder, EpicShifts — Dustin builds EpicShifts and writes about scheduling, labor cost, and shift-work operations for restaurants and other hourly teams.
Pricing and details reflect each company's publicly listed information as of June 2026 and may have changed — please verify on their websites. All product names are trademarks of their respective owners; EpicShifts is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by them. Comparison provided for informational purposes.We use cookies to improve your experience on our platform. Essential cookies are required for the site to function properly (authentication, security). Optional cookies help us understand how you use the site and improve our services. Learn more about cookies